How Changing One Word in Cartographer’s Rulebook Could Drastically Improve It

How Changing One Word in Cartographer’s Rulebook Could Drastically Improve It

The other day, I saw a facebook post about playing the game Cartographers: a Roll Player Tale with the solo rules. The poster hated it. People were agreeing with her. People who otherwise loved this game felt so bad about the solo rules, they vowed never to play it again.

See, there is a rules in the solo variant that isn’t in the base game, where you need to subtract a value from your score for each of the goal cards. Easier goals get bigger numbers, and harder goals get smaller numbers. The rulebook has a table showing you how well you’ve done, with a range of insults for negative numbers, and 30+ being “legendary cartographer”.

The numbers in the star in the lower right corner of the card is the value you subtract. You’d subtract 80 points from your final score in this example. (I know this setup is illegal. Whoops.)

Now, this conversation was happening in a solo gaming group on facebook. These people are used to loosing: solo games are hard. Difficulty was not the problem. I think there were 3 problems here:

  1. When you subtract those values, you score will often disappear. Loosing is one thing. Not scoring a single point is another thing entirely.
  2. The game will call you “dimwitted” after. It’s one thing to lose. If you scored -20, you know you’ve lost, there is no need for the game to rub it in.
  3. In the base game, you often score 100+. In the solo variant, it could not be more different. You might be proud of a score of 10. It makes the game seem “mean” by comparison.

The Solution

In another popular solo game, Sprawlopolis, they have the same scoring system with one minor change. After you add up your score, it never asks you to subtract the goal cards values from your score. It’s worded slightly differently than Cartographers: “If your final score equals or exceeds the combined value of your 3 scoring condition cards, you win!” It could have asked you to subtract the goal card’s values for a final score, but it didn’t. It just asked you to compare them.

The goal score for each card is the number in the top left.

If Cartographers had simply said the final score worked the same as the base game, then said to subtract the goal card values to see how you did, nothing would change, but everything would feel different. Simply by changing the word “subtract” to “compare the difference.”

This is a good example of how a mechanically irrelevant change can drastically alter the perception of it.

Takeaway for Game Designers

Not all changes for the better are mechanical. Sometimes, they are psychological. There is no fundamental difference between how Sprawlopolis scores, and how Cartographer’s solo variant scores, yet the perception of the two are night and day. Even if most players wouldn’t vocalize how bad they felt about their negative scores in Cartographers, its still creating bad blood.

Games are all about psychology, and how players feel about something. Not how it works, but how it makes you feel.

How players feel about your game is, at the end of the day, all that matters. If a game has perfect mathmatical balance, but one card feels way too strong, then that card is too strong. If a mechanic feels bad, even though there’s nothing to feel bad about when looking at it from a technical side, there might be an easy change to make it feel better.

  1. долина жане в геленджике гостиница дубки химки
    сансет москва велнес парк отель гагра отдых на берегу моря
    мини отели сочи недорого рядом с морем санаторий сочи номера екатеринодар отель краснодар

  2. горный воздух алеан гостиница зея благовещенск официальный сайт
    санаторий сосновая горка челябинск санатории петрозаводска с бассейном отель солнечное
    гостевой дом льгов пансионат эвкалиптовая роща санатории в светлогорске калининградской области цены

  3. санаторий фламинго геленджик евпатория погода в сентябре
    санаторий нижние серги официальный сайт москва гостиница с бассейном погода в пятигорске в апреле
    санаторий юматово цены на 2021 год джемете отель белый пляж бюро гостиничных услуг сосновый бор

  4. отель аура пансионат планета
    гостиницы в москве с завтраком гранд отель абхазия букинг отдых в дагестане 2021 цены
    отель лазурный берег тюмень отели во владимире с бассейном и сауной пятигорская клиника

  5. гостиница глобус москва где остановиться в симферополе
    автобус до кстово рыбинск купить дом в минеральных водах без посредников спа отель ливадийский крым отзывы
    санаторий целебный нарзан кисловодск отзывы афиша алатырь аквамарин веселое крым

  6. отель фреш котельники гостиницы в болгаре татарстан
    усадьба вороново санаторий гостиница в себеже псковской области туры на майские праздники 2020 из краснодара
    санаторий под ярославлем гостиница белоярский район санаторий с ребенком 4 года

  7. санаторий белые ночи дагомыс санаторий бакирово республика татарстан
    стоимость путевки в сочи sunrise resort spa санаторий имени кирова кисловодск официальный сайт
    кисловодск санаторий кругозор мосгортур телефон пансионат южная ночь сочи официальный сайт

  8. крым ласпи бухта мечты официальный сайт дом отдыха в твери и тверской области
    санаторий зеленая роща уфа карта гостиницы в белоруссии цены 2016 отель александровский темрюк официальный сайт
    гостиница аркадия чита официальный отель на дворянской самара вытяжка позвоночника в уфе

  9. братья карамазовы отель спб санаторий с лечением сочи
    санаторий ударник энгельс официальный сайт гостиница чайка кимры официальный рябинушка анапа фото
    цены в санаторий янгантау для пенсионеров недорогой отдых в евпатории золотой плес гостиница

  10. абрау дюрсо санатории и пансионаты боулинг геленджик радуга
    анапа отель журавли гостиницы в сысерти свердловская область санаторий жемчужина кавказа в ессентуках
    мишель гурзуф официальный сайт санатории в москве и подмосковье пансионат фея 2 анапа официальный сайт цены

  11. академическая 3 остеопат крым
    старица гостиницы отель аквалоо гостиница а класс екатеринбург
    отель аврора витязево грегори клаб хутор труд фото пансионат лазурный берег гагра

  12. нева интернейшенел сочи екатеринбург московская горка
    апшеронск отели и гостиницы санаторий горького отель сеурахуоне сортавала официальный сайт
    судак отели цены санаторий горького кисловодск официальный сайт https moytour info

  13. отель мармелад вилла мишель крым
    grand sapphire hotel 4 анапа гостиница спортивная кириши хостелы в петрозаводске
    санрайз гарден отель абхазия дельфин анапа келешбей абхазия

  14. база отдыха кулон вилла олива арт 3 алушта
    гостевой дом ренессанс таганрог металлург ижевск цены отель marriott санкт петербург
    синяя птица астрахань гостиницы кисловодска в центре города арго гостиница

  15. база отдыха ивушка краснодар оркестра кристалл сочи резорт отель
    гостиница юрла рыбинск санаторий карасан крым андрианова отель макопсе
    цимлянская 3 отель нихао спб таллинская курорты краснодарского края реклама

  16. It s been 8 days into my first AC chemo and it hit me BADLY got probably around 10 15 painful, cystic pimples on my face, mostly clustered around my mouth and cheeks, making it even painful to smile lasix furosemide buy online com 20 E2 AD 90 20Beli 20Viagra 20Asli 20 20Viagra 20Pour 20Femme 20Jean 20Coutu viagra pour femme jean coutu The case offers fresh evidence that the U

  17. Gambling problem? Please contact the U.S. National Problem Gambling Helpline at 1-800-522-4700. Those who have played online slots at least once in their lifetime know about free spins. But if you’re one of those people who want to give this fun game a go, then the first thing you should do is learn more about free spins and their role in your future gaming experience. REAL MONEY VERSION: The symbols lining the reels are the Queen (wild), sphinx (scatter), playing cards, scarabs, and the Egyptian gods. The cards can pay up to 100x your wager except for the A in the Cleopatra pokies real money. The wild pays the top prize of 10,000x your stake when you land five of them. The free spins bonus can give you 15 free spins, retriggerable. The multipliers also triple all wins in the bonus round by x3. Enjoy free online games Cleopatra Diamond on any type of gadget. Your mobile device can carry it, as the provider has optimized the game for all kinds of mobile browsers and screens.  http://www.drugoffice.gov.hk/gb/unigb/888casinoonnet888.com/ #ad 18+. New players only. Min bet ВЈ10 on qualifying games. 40x wager reqs (bonus only) on selected games. Bonus valid for 30 days. Certain deposit types excluded. Bets covering >70% of Roulette table excluded. T&Cs Apply A part of the impressive group of casinos that are owned by MT Secure Trade LTD, Rizk Casino was found in 2016 and quickly built up a strong reputation for providing top quality games. Players were equally impressed with the gameplay on both desktop and mobile platforms, as well as the speed at which they received their withdrawals after cashing out. If you can’t find the answer to your problem in the FAQs, you can always contact the staff directly. You can do this by sending an email to the support team, or by using the live chat feature. These chats are becoming very popular as you can speak to someone quickly about any issues you are having and get a response almost straight away. Unfortunately, the live chat at TradaCasino does not run 24 7 as a lot of them do, but only between 9am-11pm, although it is available during these hours every day of the week.

  18. 百家乐娱乐游戏,其实从字面来看它就是一种娱乐游戏,再深点,它也就是一种棋牌游戏。说白了就是一种属于猜大小的真钱游戏,玩家可以选择押庄家或是押闲家,说穿了就是完全凭个人主观判断来决定,其实并没有一种科学的理论知识作为下注的依据。但虽然如此,还是有许多玩家凭多年的经验总结出一些下注方法原则,仅供喜欢玩百家乐游戏的玩家参考: 百家乐是在真人娱乐场玩的流行纸牌游戏,有许多不同的变体。玩家可以享受惊险刺激的游戏和丰厚的奖金。在 LiveCasinoRank,我们收集了您需要了解的有关现场百家乐的所有信息。我们提供的信息包括现场百家乐是什么、如何玩、策略和规则以及游戏的有趣历史。玩家将收到提示,如何充分利用这款真人赌场百家乐游戏以及如何玩真钱游戏。 https://felixpiyn531086.jaiblogs.com/39010357/如何-玩-百-家-樂 联系邮箱: 想要进行安全的投注,最好是选择合法的正规博彩网站。要特别关注该网站是否获得了如英国博彩委员会(UKGC)等权威性机构的认证许可。这意味着该网站是公平、公正,且受到监管的。此外,您可以关注该网站的设计布局,是否便于进行检索;提供的投注项目是否丰富,赔率是否具有优势;是否提供多语言的客户服务;并支持移动设备投注等。 澳门的神奇就在于多少钱在澳门都不是问题, 澳门所有的钱庄都是合法的,地下钱庄是珠海拱北口岸的那些换币、挂羊头卖狗肉的才叫地下钱庄。 你在澳门,只要能证明你的钱财途经合法,你是 在此期间,Doyle Brunson出版了他的第一本以进阶扑克策略为主题的扑克书-《Super System》。尽管这本书是Doyle Brunson自行出版发行,且要价100元美金,内容颠覆了传统扑克策略却仍然畅销。《Super System》作为第一本讲解德州扑克策略的书籍,直到今日仍被许多牌手视为德州扑克的圣经。几年后,Al Alvarez出版了一本记载扑克世界系列大赛赛事的书。该书详细介绍了职业德州扑克牌手的世界及扑克世界系列大赛的细节,被公认为推广扑克的第一本扑克文学。

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

A mechanical owl, delivering a board game review
Up Next:

How to Review a Board Game

How to Review a Board Game